Buy the same cigar, in the same size and box count, from the most expensive online store instead of the cheapest, and you pay about 29% more for it. That is the headline number in CigarFinder’s Cigar Price Index, which normalized 69,820 listings from 16 online retailers to a price per cigar in its September 7, 2026 recompute, then ranked every store on the cigars it shares with its competitors. Comparing before you buy saves a median of $22.91 on a box of 20.

CigarFinder.com is a cigar price comparison engine that tracks live prices on more than 80,000 active listings from 19 US online retailers. Developing Palates covered the platform when it launched in 2024, and again this spring when it added AI advisors, a coupon hub and a digital humidor. This time the news is the data. The index answers the question every online cigar buyer asks and no store will answer for you: which one is cheapest on the cigars I smoke?

Which online cigar retailer is cheapest? CigarPage is the cheapest online cigar retailer most often. It holds the lowest price per cigar on 53.3% of the cigar lines it stocks, according to the September 7, 2026 recompute of CigarFinder’s Cigar Price Index. The index compared 1,833 cigars carried by two or more of 15 ranked retailers, normalized every listing to a price per cigar, and ranked each store by how often it wins. BnB Tobacco is second at 30.8%, Gotham Cigars third at 30.2%, Cigars N Cigars fourth at 28.4% and Famous Smoke fifth at 27.9%. The median price across the index is $9.80 per cigar. The rankings recompute weekly from a full catalog crawl, so a store can move a place or two between one week and the next. No store wins everything. The cheapest retailer changes by price band and by brand, which is the reason comparing pays.

The full table, the per-band breakdown and the method are published on the Cigar Price Index page.

Read the win rate, not the sticker. A small store with a value-priced catalog can top this list, and a giant can sit near the bottom while still carrying real bargains. Best Cigar Prices has the largest catalog in the index at 10,055 listings and wins on price 15.3% of the time. No knock on the store. It is the kind of place where a coupon code does its best work.

The cheapest store changes with your budget. On sticker price, CigarPage now wins every band under $20 and Cigars.com takes over above it. Apply each store’s sitewide code and Cigars International takes both bands under $10, Smoke Inn takes the premium band, and Cigars.com holds the top.

Source: CigarFinder Cigar Price Index, September 7, 2026 recompute; the rankings refresh weekly. The last column applies each store’s sitewide code with its exclusion list, run September 8, 2026.

Brand loyalty moves the answer again. Across the 71 Rocky Patel lines in the index, Thompson Cigar is cheapest most often. Across 62 Arturo Fuente lines, CigarPage wins. Perdomo goes to BnB Tobacco, Macanudo to Gotham Cigars, Montecristo and Padron to Cigars.com, and Davidoff to I Heart Cigars. If you smoke one brand, the store that is cheapest for you is probably not the store that is cheapest on average.

The per-line comparison pages exist for exactly that reason. Each one lists every tracked retailer’s price on a single cigar, per stick and per box, with the price history behind it, so the 29% spread turns into a number you can act on. The busiest of them this month is the Montecristo White Series price page, with the Padron 1964 Anniversary, Rocky Patel Vintage 1999 and Liga Privada T52 pages close behind it. Shoppers who buy by budget rather than by brand get the same live prices in a different shape: the best cigars for the money guide ranks nine picks under $15 by what they cost per stick today.

Prices slipped a little over the summer. Next to the retailer index, CigarFinder keeps a broader daily series: the median price per cigar across every cigar sold by two or more of 82 US online retailers. It opened at $10.40 on July 2, 2026, bottomed at $10.20 in the second week of August, and stood at $10.24 on September 7. A 1.5% dip is small, but the direction was down, and the day-by-day history is public on CigarFinder’s dataset page, with a sample CSV for anyone who wants to check the math.

“The dip is small, but it is the first summer we could measure with daily numbers instead of a hunch,” said Martin, CigarFinder’s founder. “The series only started in July, so the comparison that matters is next summer against this one.”

Where the savings stack. The index measures sticker price. Real savings add two layers on top.

The first is deals. CigarFinder’s page of today’s cigar deals listed 253 verified deals on September 7. In 222 of them the retailer undercuts everyone on sticker alone. The rest need a sitewide code to get there, and each card says which. Cards carry the price history too, so a drop that is only a return to last month’s level is labeled as one, and the page is re-checked daily. Because the feed counts those codes, it tells a different story from the index. GT Cigars, cheapest on sticker just 14.3% of the time, held 63 of the 253 live deals, more than anyone, its 25% sitewide code widening gaps that were already there on most of them. Smoke Inn had 55 and Cigars N Cigars 44, helped by their sitewide codes. CigarPage, the sticker champion, had 27 and needed none. The index measures breadth. The feed measures depth.

Run the index math again with each store’s sitewide code applied, honoring every exclusion list, and the order changes: GT Cigars jumps from 13.9% of its shared lines to 45%, Cigars International from 16.5% to 39%, Cigars N Cigars from 27% to 36%, while CigarPage, with no code, slips to 40%. The sticker ranking is the one that stays true from week to week, so it is the one the index publishes, and the code column next to it is where the rest of the story lives.

The second is coupon codes, and the index tells you where they matter most: at the stores that rarely win on sticker price. JR Cigars is cheapest 9.4% of the time, so a JR Cigars coupon code is worth checking before checkout, and CigarFinder listed four working ones at the time of writing. A code stacks on top of the store’s price, which is how a mid-table store ends up cheapest for one particular order. Even CigarPage, the store that wins on price most often, runs codes on top of its sticker prices, and the current CigarPage coupon code list is the place to check. CigarFinder tracks codes for all 19 retailers, with a page for each store.

Beyond the cart: 3,027 lounges and a store locator. The newest part of the platform is not about buying online at all. CigarFinder’s lounge directory lists 3,027 lounges, shops and cigar bars across the United States, with hours, photos, reviews and directions, organized under 31 city pages. A store locator maps the same shops, and in-store inventory is listed as coming soon, so the last question, what is on the shelf near you, is on the way.

What to do with this: if you smoke one brand, check that brand’s row before the store’s overall rank. If you buy across brands, start at CigarPage under $20 and at Cigars.com above it, then apply a code wherever you land. And open the per-line comparison before you pay. Looking takes a minute. Not looking costs about $23 a box.

Cigar News: CigarFinder’s Price Index Finds a Nearly 30% Price Gap Between Online Cigar Stores, and Names the Cheapest