Concept
This list is based on our review results and it is calculated based on weighting the ranking of each reviewers individual list and then totaling that number for each cigar and then ranking the cigars based on the total scores from that weighting.
To read the full review on any of these cigars, just click on the cigar name.
There are links to each reviewers list below the singular list to show full transparency.
Also, be sure to check out our video recap which is located just below the lists.
Criteria
- Only cigars that were released between September 1, 2022 and October 31, 2023 are eligible
- Cigar has to have been reviewed on the site by all four members of the team
Top 25 Cigars of 2023
1. Patina Anniversary
2. HVC Selección No. 1 Esenciales
3. Highclere Castle Senetjer
4. Gurkha Colección Especial Lonsdale
5. Dunbarton Tobacco & Trust Mi Querida Black PapaSaka
6. Black Works Studio S&R 2023 Corona Larga
7. RoMa Craft Intemperance Volstead VO 1920 Noble Experiment
8. JRE Aladino Classic Elegante
9. Tatuaje 20th Anniversary Grande Merveille
10. Illusione Original Documents Habano Corona Gorda
11. Drew Estate Liga Privada H99 Connecticut Corojo Papas Fritas
12. Espinosa Knuckle Sandwich Connecticut Short Churchill G
13. HVC Selección No. 1 Natural Esenciales
14. Davidoff Year of the Rabbit Limited Edition 2023
15. Espinosa Las 6 Provincias CMW
16. Meerapfel Meir Robusto
17. Montecristo FSG Toro
18. Black Label Trading Company Bishops Blend Novemdiales Toro
19. JRE Aladino Limited Edition
20. Rocky Patel DBS Robusto
21. CLE PCA 2023 Exclusive 50×5
22. (Tie) Alfonso Añejos No. 2
22. (Tie) HVC La Rosa 520 Rare of Rare
24. Casa 1910 Soldadera Edition Teniente Angela
25. Topper 125th Anniversary
Feedback
Let us know your thoughts on our lists. We want to hear it all.










Leave a Reply