The Saint Luis Rey Eiroa 30th Anniversary Rothchilde is an overall great cigar being candy like in sweet and creaminess with balancing earthiness and spice. But whomever the QC team is for this company needs a talking to. There's no reason to apply such an ugly cap to an overall good looking cigar.
The Saint Luis Rey Tabacales Toro is a technically sound cigar that delivers a reliable, traditional profile but lacks the depth or evolution needed to elevate it beyond Average. It’s a cigar that doesn't leave a lasting impression once finished.
The first third of the Saint Luis Rey Carenas Robusto started out promising, with some flavors that became balanced about halfway through. The second and final thirds were quite linear, not offering up much in the way of complexity to keep me engaged. Given that the price point on the Carenas Robusto is fairly average for the marketplace, there isn't much about the flavor delivery that would interest me in coming back.